President Bush - Contrasting The Decision Making Skills Of Jfk And George W. Bush

Presidents of the United States can only makeoffice that George Washington held, and Thomas
decisions based on the information they are gettingJefferson, Abraham Lincoln, both Roosevelt's, Teddy,
from the people and other sources that are availableand Franklin. Those thoughts and heritages never
to them. Different Presidents obtain that data flow inleave your mind when you are in the room with that
different ways. This is particularly important becauseman regardless of who he is.
the events we are dealing with are so much moreNow let's take a look at President Bush. Contrary to
crucial than other Presidents may be dealing with.some people's thoughts this is not a dumb man. He
Iraq, North Korea, high gasoline prices, competitivehas degrees from both Yale, and Harvard Business. A
position versus China, long-term deficits are all hugelot was handed to him in life, but he also knew how
problems that must be solved one way or another.to play a pretty good hand. He has to his detriment
President Kennedy had an open door policy. Hein my opinion surrounded himself with arrogant,
functioned as his own chief of staff, a center of theideological, one-dimensional minds with limited capacity
spokes strategy if you will. It was highly successful.for growth.
Unlike this President, Kennedy asked incisiveDick Cheney is brilliant. He is also arrogant, secretive,
questions, and followed up with more incisiveand ideological. Cheney has hurt this President by not
questions. JFK developed his decision making skillsgrowing his own thinking over the last six years. The
very quickly. He was not like this on day one, but heway he thought in the early 1990's, is the same way
certainly was at the top of his game by year two ofhe is thinking today. The VP's secretiveness as
his Administration. In year one, Kennedy learned notopposed to openness has cost the President dearly
to trust the CIA, or the military. Both organizationsin our need to safeguard the people's constitutional
had failed him at the Bay of Pigs in Cuba.rights regarding privacy.
When JFK came into office, he was presented with aDonald Rumsfeld is the worst Secretary of Defense
CIA plan created during the Eisenhowersince Robert McNamara. Both McNamara and
Administration to land 1500 expatriate Cubans in CubaRumsfeld seem to be almost identical in their
to unseat Fidel Castro. The CIA pushed the plan hard,arrogance. He is sad to watch Rumsfeld repeat the
and the military sat it out when it came time tosame pattern of arrogance that caused McNamara to
speak. The disastrous invasion which took place inlead this country down the path of suicide during the
April 1961, four months after the inauguration was aViet Nam debacle. Rumsfeld inability to entertain new
wakeup call for JFK. To his dying days, JFK said, "Iideas is costing us dearly in Iraq. His bullying of the
asked the wrong questions."generals who are charged with the responsibility to
He said that if he had it to do over, he would havewage the war is inexcusable, and history will not
told the Joint Chiefs, "I want to make this antreat this man kindly.
American operation, forget the 1500 Cubans, let's doNow what do you think happens when the President
it with our military. How many Marines do we have tohas men like Cheney and Rumsfeld around him? The
send in to do this right?" The answer the Joint Chiefsproblem is that everybody else is speaking in that
would have given was 250,000 marines. JFK had helow voice, afraid to utter what they perceive is the
known this would have immediately cancelled thetruth to the President. This would all be okay except
invasion. He would have said to himself how can 1500the President hasn't figured out the game yet. He
poorly trained Cubans do the job that we woulddoesn't understand how to get the information he
need 250,000 Marines to do? The president picked upneeds to make good, solid decisions that WORK.
ten years of experience in those first few months.In his press conference today, the President said that
The next major tool we can learn from JFK is the"I feel confident when General Casey (4 star
use of an executive committee (ExComm) in timesgeneral-Vice Chief of Staff-US Army, and
of national crisis. When the Cuban Missile Crisis tookCommander of Multi-National Force-Iraq) tells me
place, JFK did not round up the usual suspects to dealwhat's on his mind." General Casey could never tell
with the crisis. He brought together the best mindsthe President what's on his mind, and that's the
he knew, put them in a room and let them deal withproblem with this whole Administration. The President
the crisis alone. He would periodically enter the room,is not getting the information he needs to deal with
find out what was going on, and leave again. Hethe problem whatever it might be.
knew that people react differently when theIn being spoon fed the equivalent of ideological
President is in the room. His presence completelydogma, the President is finding himself in a position
jaded the conversation and advice that would comethat JFK would say is unacceptable. Even Richard
out of such a meeting.Nixon a very strong conservative thinker had Daniel
This brings us to President Bush. I do not know ifPatrick Moynihan a very liberal Harvard Professor
you have ever been in the Oval Office or at aright next to him giving the President the other side
meeting with a sitting President of the United States.of the story. If Mr. Bush is to succeed in the
Let me tell you what it's like. Everybody speaks withremaining two years of this Presidency, he has to
a soft voice in his presence. It's like they arestart hearing the other side of the story. I do not
whispering. Grown men who command corporationshave much hope that this is going to happen, and our
with hundreds of thousands of employees turn tobiggest problem which is the quagmire in Iraq will
mush in his presence. It doesn't matter who thecontinue until new leadership is elected with the
President is, the reaction is always the same. It'smandate to change. Of course the ideologues will
cultural; we are brought up to respect the office andsay, we should have stayed the course. History will
the sacredness of the office. After all, this is theshow them wrong.